Liberating the Charism
Provocations for a Hermeneutics of “Charism”
The risk we run and the sense of liberation of charism
As noted by Donal Dorr, there is today the real risk that a missionary Congregation might indeed acknowledge in principle the new frontiers of mission, but in practice continue to live, think and act within the traditional ‘missionary world’, by appealing as justification to “its charism”. In this way, charism is reduced to tradition and the appeal to it ends up by blocking or inhibiting any creativity and change.
In fact, in these last decades, grappling with social, cultural and ecclesial transformations of epochal character and with all their ‘critical’ implications of ministerial and existential ‘challenge’, the appeal to the ‘codified’ charism of the Founder and of the Institute has become more and more insistent. Paradoxically, however, precisely such clinging to the charism-tradition in order to safeguard our distinct missionary character, conceived according to the old model of “foreign missions” for the “conversion of non-Christians”, runs the risk of provoking that very crisis that it would like to avoid. Moreover, by remaining bound to the traditional way of being missionaries, we might find ourselves outside today’s missionary frontiers of the Church.
A theological re-visitation, then, of the meaning of a charism in the Church is necessary. The courage is needed to put under scrutiny that massive appeal to the Founder and to his missionary methodology, so that it might not become an obstruction, but rather potentialities latent (hidden) in the charismatic event of which the Institute lives might be freed, the memory of charism might turn into a creative capacity in the encounter with today’s missionary realities and nourish a new, inedited missionary imagination.
These few pages are intended to be a contribution to this process of discernment and liberation of the charism. They will present some provocative theses, which should not be taken separately but rather in their reciprocity and interaction.
1. Charism as ‘empowerment’: ‘capacity’ of acting in the power of the Spirit who “renews the face of the earth”
In the New Testament the community of the Lord’s disciples is enriched, in each one of its members, with gifts of grace (charisma/charismata from the other Greek word charis, grace) through which the creative and renewing vitality (energeia, energy – another name for charism) of the Spirit as the “eschatological Gift” itself (pneumatika, again another designation for charism, from Pneuma) is manifested.
These New Testament data contain important indications for a theological re-reading of charism.
It is, first of all, underlined that charism means an irruption of the Holy Spirit, wind that “blows where it chooses”. As such, charism speaks of event and movement: the language, namely, of actuality, that resists a too easy translation in terms of institution and of a tradition to which to conform. Constitutive of every charism is rather an aspect of ‘surprise’, as imprint of the God who in self-giving continues to remain ‘other’ and ‘hidden’ – namely, non tameable –, and builds the community of his Kingdom as an ‘open community’, sacrament of a ‘future that cannot be planned’, since the ultimate contours of God’s dream for the world remain known to Him alone
As manifestation of the power of the Spirit, charism represents, moreover, a dynamic and performative reality : before designating an assigned task or an ambit of work, charism is ‘grace’ that ‘enables’, in the sense that it makes us capable of translating into reality the dream of God for the world. The appropriation of this positive meaning of charism as ‘given potentiality’, divine endowment, is decisive for that economy of the Utopia of the Promise that characterizes Christian experience, namely in order to hope in something that is ‘out of place (topos)’ in the present order of things: “Send your Spirit, O Lord, and renew the face of the earth”.
As expression of the Spirit, Gift of the last days, charism introduces into the flow of God’s self-gift to the world. It is then a personal and relazional event. Charism, even if shared by a group, involves always the disciple of the Lord personally, and his/her story is called to become a mediation of God’s gift to the world, in a twofold and constitutive relationship with the Spirit of God, on the one hand, and with the contextual reality of the world and of the Christian community, on the other hand. Ultimately, charism exists only as personalized in the believing subject itself, who thus in his/her historical concreteness, with all his/her limits and conditioning, becomes sacrament of God who gives himself so that the world might live.
But, if charism is a surprise of the Spirit of God, how can we verify its authenticity? By facing always anew the story of Jesus.
2. Charism as participation in the messianic unction of Jesus
Every gift of the Spirit refers to the fullness of the same Spirit with which Jesus himself was filled:
“God anointed Jesus of Nazareth with the Holy Spirit and with power, and he went about doing good and healing all who were oppressed by the devil” (Acts 10:38)
“The Spirit of the Lord is upon me, because he has anointed me to bring good news to the poor. He has sent me to proclaim release to the captives and recovery of sight to the blind, to let the oppressed go free, to proclaim the year of the Lord’s favour.…Today this scripture has been fulfilled in your hearing” (Lk 4:18-21)
The Lukan literature joins together the event of Jesus’ baptism at Jordan and the event of Pentecost, the mission of Jesus and the mission of the disciples. Every charism is a participation in the unction of Jesus, the Messiah, enabled thus to inaugurate the feast of God’s kingdom as an event of healing, liberation and abundance of life.
To face the story of Jesus-the Messiah constitutes another fundamental criterion for a theological reinterpretation of charism. Here two aspects need to be underlined.
Placed in relationship with the spiritual unction of Jesus, charisms, in all their variety, are all making present and visible the “newness” of Christ event within the historical particularity of the ‘today’ of human beings, their cultures and societies. If a “tradition” of charism is given, paradoxically it cannot be other than a memory that actualizes and displays the newness of Jesus-the Messiah. And since Jesus is now the Risen One who lives for ever, charism looks neither back nor acts in the name of someone who is absent: in the different charisms it is the Lord himself who acts and it is his “exousia” (power, authority) of salvation that is manifested.
Consequently, as participation in the messianic unction of Jesus, all charisms in the Church are qualified as missionary. Furthermore, the truth of every charism, starting with those that are specifically defined as missionary and with the so called ‘foundational’ charisms themselves, remains bound to a constant process of discernment, in a comparison with the story of Jesus and the integrity of mission as lived by him, and in relation to the ever new historical situations. Thus, the reference to the “proclamation of the kingdom of God to the poor”, as expression of the messianic dream of Jesus, and to its prophetic/provocative and proleptic/anticipative character, is of a decisive importance for a charism to release all its ‘spiritual potentiality’ (= the power of Spirit), beyond its particular historical configuration. Similarly, a sign of charismatic authenticity is the capacity of giving concrete form to ‘God’s com-passion’, which, in its twofold meaning of shared suffering and liberating action, constitutes the heart itself of Jesus’ messianic ministry and of his spiritual testament (cf. Mt 25:31-46).
3. Charism as ecclesial event: The Church as a constellation of charisms and the charismatic identity as an identity of participation and communion
As participation in the messianic unction of Jesus by the Spirit, charisms manifest and build up the ‘anointed body’ of Christ: all of them are rooted in the common baptismal unction. Instead of being in contradiction, the ‘personal’ and ‘ecclesial’ dimensions of charism converge, by defining anew the person of the Lord’s disciple in relational terms and the Church as communion of persons.
Here we have other important indications in order to come out of the impasse that the appeal to the specificity of one’s charism may cause, and thus let the charism release all its ‘inedited’ potentiality.
First of all, charisms design the Church itself as an event of personal relationships, more than as an institution. The Church is depicted as a constellation of disciples-bearers of gifts, who interact among them and mirror each other, through reciprocal witness and welcome, by sharing each one, according to the grace received, the one mission of Jesus, namely the same dream and concern of God for the world. Like a comet, each charism spreads around a halo of light that goes beyond the one who bears it and in which other disciples can recognize and place themselves, by making it in their turn shine with new intensity and colours. Not a fixed constellation, but a “kinetic” figure: a Church-movement under the thrust of the Spirit, that blow of God that led Jesus in his life and ministry.
Secondly, in this perspective, a charism has an open identity, defined by ‘inclusion’, namely through participation and communion, rather than by exclion; an identity, moreover, shared and relived by other subjects, and so capable of new developments. In other words, the charism of a Christian is not something that the other members of the Church do not have; rather, the charism of each one manifests and promotes a charismatic trait of the Church, the anointed body of Christ: circularity is established both between the individual members and the body as a whole. Thus, there are in the Church prophets and missionaries, because the Church as a whole is by nature prophetic and missionary; while, on the other hand, the Church as a whole remains prophetic and missionary because of the presence in it of prophets and missionaries. Thus, it is not surprising, for example, that “to be for the poorest and most abandoned” can be found as a specific element of the charism of so many ecclesial groups. In realty, the option for the poor is a fundamental qualification of the Church as such in its messianic identity and mission. Is, in fact, not the proclamation of the kingdom of God to the poor and the last, done both among the poor and the rich themselves, the messianic event of the Good News, liberating beatitude for the former and redemptive mercy for the latter?
At this point, one could ask whether the whole question of these last years about our Comboni identity represents a misunderstanding rather than a desire of charismatic authenticity, as it were a continuous “look at one’s own navel” and an effect of a pathological feature of our time withdrawn as it is into itself and suspicious of newly emerging ‘otherness’. Could not such obsession with one’s own identity reproduce at the end those “fraterie” which Comboni abhorred?
Where, would, then, lie the fidelity to the Comboni Charism? How should Comboni charism be understood?
4. Charism of “foundation” as a living realty with its own history: Historical praxis as ‘locus’ of charism discernment and the inedited richness of the original charismatic event
What has been said up to now introduces a dimension of “souplesse” in the consideration of a ‘corporate’ charism as that of an Institute, in our case, of the Comboni Institute.
Firstly, it is necessary to distinguish between the personal charism of the Founder and the charism –so to say- of “foundation”, as it is lived and articulated in the life of his followers; in the case of the Comboni Institute, between Comboni’s charism and the Comboni charism. Referring again to the symbology of constellation, within the great constellation of the Church as communion of charisms – itself as the ‘halo’ of the messianic charism of Jesus – other minor constellations are formed around some particular charismatic figures, in such a way that between the principle figure of the Founder and his followers as well as among the followers themselves the same dynamic of reciprocity that exists in the great ecclesial constellation is renewed. That entails that the charism of ‘foundation’ is a dynamic and historical reality with its own even unpredictable development: an event that is handed down in time in that it continues to happen in the present, in ways that are different and new.
It is in the history of the community that draws inspiration from him and in the personal story of each of its members that the memory of the Founder comes true (is fulfilled), in conformity to that ecclesial model that is typified in the liturgical memory, namely as part of the more comprehensive memory of Christ and in virtue of the re-creating action of the Spirit. The continuity between the event of the Founder and the event of his community in the various times and places is of historic-salvific order. The identity of the charism of foundation cannot be established purely on the basis of a historical reconstruction of its original moment. Continuity and identity ‘happen’ rather, as a re-invention of the Spirit which is to be discerned and complied with, within a history in becoming. We can know how that history started but not how it will develop. The handing on of the charism is itself a charismatic event.
The true re-appropriation of the Founder resists any attempt at exhuming his ‘dead body’ in order to cling to it. This would make of him an object of the past, a ‘dead’, and he would no longer be a ‘living one’ in the Lord. As he was a living interpretation of the Lord and of his messianic mission, so only in that he is, in his turn, reinterpreted in the ‘today’ of the Church and of mission, as well as in the life of each one of his followers, can he continue to be a source of inspiration and signify the charism of foundation. In view of such hermeneutical process, the historical-critical study represents certainly an indispensable condition, as it is also necessary for nourishing a concrete communion between him and his community through time. However, decisive and conclusive it remains always how the Spirit, who animated the Founder by making a symbol of life for others, makes his spiritual inheritance be re-read and actualized within the new historical contexts. Significant in this regard is the fact that the affirmation of his death is part of the liturgical memory of a Founder: death physical and symbolic at the same time, as necessary moment of separation, in order to let the Spirit free and the Founder’s spiritual descendants grow. After all, Jesus himself could say of himself: “It is to your advantage that I go away, for if I do not go away, the Advocate will not come to you; but if I go, I will send him to you” (Jn 16:7).
It is necessary therefore to read the charism of an Institute in a historical key and in a dynamic perspective. Not only the Founder needs to be read within his own historical context, so as to capture his prophetic indications as well as to specify inevitable conditioning and limits; it is as much necessary to scrutinize the subsequent journey of the Institute, both in its communal choices and in the life and work of its members, in order to identify which new spaces the Spirit opens up to the charism of foundation and of which new meaning it enriches it. The charism of foundation, as a ‘pneumatic-ecclesial’ reality, is defined as much from the past of the Founder as from the future of those who follow in his footsteps: moving maybe from totally new contexts, these, in the concreteness of their vocation and of the grace that has been given them, are themselves the on-going interpretation of the charism. The incorporation and integration into an Institute is a two-way movement, or better a mysterious exchange: not only each member grows into the image of the Founder, but the Founder himself grows in the image always new and different of those who follow him; mysterious exchange, because such reciprocity articulates the freedom of the Spirit who guides the Church in its mission. In this way, the Holy Spirit, as the Divine Artist, not only recreates the figure of the Founder, but moreover unveils new traits of the face of Christ, and opens up new unexplored routes for the realization of his messianic mission.
All this signifies that the historical praxis itself constitutes a privileged locus for an on-going discernment of the charism of foundation. This demands a ‘dynamic-inductive’ approach that lets the historical event challenge the text of the tradition of the Founder and of the Institute, rather than a ‘static-deductive’ approach concerned with ‘putting order’ into the event.
After all, there is always something inedited in each charismatic event, starting with the event itself of Christ. The original moment of that event continues to have a normative meaning for the subsequent history. But, on the other hand, it is precisely the subsequent historical praxis that displays the hidden richness of the original event and releases its internal potentialities. In order to recognize these new frontiers of the charism, those cutting-edge experiences which perhaps look at first rather marginal to the codified life of an Institute come to have a particular value. A charismatic discernment, intent on discovering the action of the Spirit, cannot limit itself to consider whether such experiences fit in with the usual schemes of the Institutes, even if canonized by the Rule of Life. Life came before the rule. Rather, courage will be needed to “put out into the deep water and let down the nets for a catch” (Lk 5:4). Indeed, to put out into the deep water, because the charism lives always immersed in history, the place of the ‘unexpected’ rather than of ‘inevitable’, where among so many contradictions and wrongs, the Spirit of God prepares the future of the Kingdom. Within this history, the charism is the on-going translation of the “primigenia inspiratio” of the Founder, he himself a mediation of the Kingdom. Each mediation and translation has its own risks; but charism is anyway the gift of being able to fish out the newness of God’s kingdom in the most impossible waters. As says the Lord’s parable, the given talent is to be risked.
In the final analysis, the story of the Founder has an intrinsic provisional character. It remains bound to a particular time and is always relative to Christ and his mission: “He must increase, but I must decrease” (Jn 3:30). At the same time, this provisional character has also the strong and etymological meaning of ‘pro-visio’: the story of the Founder, in its relative particularity, contains a promise and outlines the vision of a reality whose realization ‘brims over’ into the future, beyond what he himself might have thought and lived. It is as if his words and his life pointed to ‘something else’ that they contain only ‘sub specie futuri’. His spiritual inheritance is so inspirational in that there are in it as it were some ‘pierres d’attente’ which as such wait to be ‘discovered’ in their value in relation to a new time and a new comprehension of the mystery of Christ and his mission that the Spirit makes grow.
Thus, with reference to Comboni, some elements of his spiritual testament, such as the “pierced heart of the Good Shepherd”, “the poorest and most abandoned”, the “catholic mission”, the “regeneration of the Nigrizia”, the “dark pearl” …, in the encounter with so different situations of today, in contact with new ecclesial experiences and with the perception of the Gospel, of the ‘poor’, the ‘heart’, the ‘regeneration’…. that the Christian community has been meanwhile maturing, can result richly evocative of new horizons and of missionary frontiers.
4. Questions about the “Comboni charism” from within today’s world and the new missionary map
What has been here outlined is only a hermeneutics – an interpretative scheme – of charism, and not an answer to how to configure today the Comboni charism.
Charism has appeared as being involved in an on-going process, in which the story of the Founder and of the Institute in the reciprocity of its members, the story and mystery of Jesus the Christ-Messiah, and the actual historical context with all problems and challenges interact. In this way, charism is neither static nor self-referential, but is rather continuously reshaped by that circular salvific movement that from the “heart of the Mystery” goes to the “heart of the world”, the world being understood as historical experience, and from the “heart of the world” to the “heart of the Mystery”.
More than answers, then, are “questions” that are offered to our “reflection”, in the etymological sense of the word, as a search that might mirror and let mutually mirror the mystery of Christ and the reality of today’s world.
Of course, today’s world is as complex as ever; actually, it is a ‘plural’ world, with very many contexts; and any analysis of it will always be relative to the specific, personal and socio-cultural as well as ideological context of the one who makes it. Perhaps, in order to free oneself somehow from such self-reference in interpreting reality and be able to feel a bit the contours of our time with our fingertips, it is necessary to place oneself at the side of those who mostly ‘suffer’ this time, in a living and disturbing contact with the suffering victims. Any reading of today’s situation that does not articulate risk, danger and violence – both suffered and inflicted – not only would be deeply partial, but even false and alienating.
Today we live in a “net-work society”. And yet to the affirmation of the ‘global capitalism’ as constitutive factor of this society corresponds a widespread poverty and the emergence of violent conflicts. The global village with its compressed space is crossed by entire masses of poor driven to emigration and exile. Men and women of different culture, religion and tradition come to live side by side but according to a dynamic of competition, intolerance, abuse and rejection. Within the new mobility of the global society, the ‘tourists’, namely the few privileged ones, clash with the many ‘vagabonds’ who desperately search for a place where to live (Zygmunt Bauman).
The paradox of the present “network society” is that it is a world without the other, when not also a world at the expenses of the other, built on processes of exclusion and expulsion. The other is seen not in him/herself but only as a ‘competitor’/‘enemy’ to be demolished or as a ‘consumer’ to be bewitched, but ultimately as something to be used and then to leave to its fate.
We have entered into the third millennium with the legacy of a century of such violence to be called the “century of genocides”, and we still find ourselves caught in its snare. The West, whose Christian matrix some people would claim, is actually thrown today into a dramatic and rather inedited contention with other areas and cultures of the planet, while the public space is severely disputed by contemporary streams of secularisation on the one hand and new waves of religiosity on the other, with a resurgence of old “dross and resentments, intolerances and fanaticisms, not rarely by exploiting the name of God to incite violence and hatred” (Sergio Zavoli).
What emerges from all this is an experiential and all-comprehensive image of our time as a time of passion, marked by so many stories of pain and oppression, so much so that a growing number of studies of different trends resorts to the shocking and disturbing image of the “concentration camp”, as an enclosed universe where human dignity no longer exists and where if any equality is given is that of ‘vulnerability’: men and women as well as entire communities may be in any moment ‘dispossessed’ of their very ‘self’, deprived of their own cultural and juridical identity, made ‘superfluous’ and ‘disposable’ precisely as human beings. The spectre of the concentration camp comes actually to haunt us again in such ‘non-places’ purposely designed for immigrants and asylum seekers and called “detention centres” or rather euphemistically “centres of temporary permanence”, “in order to differentiate them – as Zigmunt Bauman points out – from the space in which the rest of the people, the ‘normal’, ‘complete’ people live and move”. Those who arrive there “become true human waste” (Federico Stella).
A time of passion, in which the modern form of evil – the “demonic difference”, as Oliver Davies calls it- not only destroys human otherness, but in face of which God himself as “the One who is good” remains as hidden as ever. It is as if an eclipse of God enveloped the world: not only because God seems to have disappeared from the consciousness of many, especially in the post-Christian West, but also because God’s silence weighs so much that God looks as “a distant being of books and incense” (Philippe Claudel), while evil is felt so near and concrete: “God does not reveal himself anymore, he seems to hide himself in his heaven. As if disgusted by the actions of humankind” (Benedict XVI).
Precisely this last remark introduces us into a second major aspect of our time The story of passion, pain and oppression goes together with a global systemic crisis and the related loss of a ‘horizon of meaning’.
Speaking of a global systemic crisis we do not refer only to the implosion of the global economic system made manifests in a dramatic way by the recent financial crunch. Rather, the crisis of the economic-financial system highlights the risk inherent in the global society, as a kind of new mastic of the West and of the world and a new existential condition of humanity (Ulrich Beck). ‘Manufactured’ risk and ‘self-generated’ threats, produced by human being and his civilisation of ‘progress’, impossible to locate, calculate and check, from the global ecological disaster to the transnational terrorism: “We are all sitting in a Danger Room of world proportions” (Tagesanzeicher, Zurich 2006) and aboard a “Runaway World” (Anthony Giddens). Risk not only as synonym of catastrophe, but much more as an anticipation of the catastrophe itself which as such “occupies our minds and guides our actions, [and] becomes a political force that changes the world” (Ulrich Beck), by generating an “economy of fear” and making us drift toward a “totalitarianism of security”, with restrictions or even suspensions of the juridical order in the name of a ‘state of exception’ or emergency: all measures that define the ‘concentration camp’ (Giorgio Agamben). In this way, “a new conflictual dynamic of social inequalities” is born and “the staging of violence” takes place (Ulrich Beck).
No matter its dramatic character, all this, however, is still a symptom of a much deeper malaise, which relates to the general fragmentation of life paradigms and to the fall of reference values in the post-modern and post-colonial societies, namely a global crisis of legitimation and an extensive process of detraditionalisation. It is question of a loss of a ‘horizon of meaning’, represented by the fact that the trust in a living God and in a finality of history is becoming ever more unsustainable for many people. This loss of a horizon of meaning makes, in its turn, extremely tragic the experience of suffering, contradiction and evil. While the traditional “meta-narratives”, both secular and religious, have been exposed in their background of ideology and power, as equivocal foundation exercises of “absolutes”, often oppressive, ironically, a new “meta-narrative” has been asserting itself: the meta-narrative of ‘market-based globalisation’. If, on the one hand, globalisation has connected among themselves the various social, cultural, economic and political realities, on the other hand, it has led to the decline of social bonds and has ruined the social ‘capital’ of mutual responsibility and solidarity. Within this context, the new visibility itself of difference and pluralism, attained through so much struggle, risks running wild, as victim either of an individualistic sub-culture of consumerist character or of a conflictual and hegemonic manipulation in an on-going reproduction of always new processes of exclusion and expulsion.
This twofold reality of passion and of a global systemic crisis represents a crisis also for today’s Church and mission. It challenges the proclamation of God and redraws the missionary map.
First of all, global mobility upsets the missionary geography, since the so called ‘non-believers’ (the Gentes) of the traditional mission are right in the middle of the supposed Christian world, while, on the other hand, the centre of gravity of Christianity, because of the very success of that missionary action, has shifted southward to that part of the world once privileged as the place of mission, so much so that now the Christian world map is dotted all over with local Churches (Church in six Continents). Moreover, the cultural upheavals and the excesses of barbarism that have involved the North of the world in the last centuries as well as the responsibility that the North shares in the processes and evils of the global village have killed the myth of a Christian North or West. If mission was before related to the crossing of the borders, those borders have been reshuffled: the geographical borders, even between believers and non-believers, have lost most of their significance, while other ‘borders’ of anthropological, ethnic, cultural, socio-political and religious character are today crossing all places in the form of structures of separation, exclusion, suspicion, anonymity and marginalisation. In our ever more plural societies, several borders grow intertwined a bit everywhere: the “others” live side by side, day after day, and yet they just brush passed each other, without really ever looking into each other’s face. The city with its much diversity is as it were the symbol of the non-encounter, a desert of sociality.
Furthermore, within the deep systemic crisis that afflicts today’s world, the proclamation of the Good News of God’s Kingdom cannot surely limit itself to make new Christians. That proclamation is rather challenged in its capacity of regenerating a collective hope and recreating society according to a new model of citizenship based on mutual responsibility and solidarity, on giving and belonging, where justice becomes the public name of ‘love’: a society as “the home we build together” (Jonathan Sachs), each one with his/her distinct gift, in which, exactly because all though different feel at home, God might feel himself home again in our world. Such missionary expectation, far from being an attempt at restoring a past that has lost its legitimacy – the re-composition of a kind of Christendom or anyway of a socio-political monolithic system, an illusion pursued by many of today’s both secular and ecclesial movements, urges the charisms in what defines them, namely to be a Spirit’s ‘empowerment’ to draw out from the present chaos the future of God.
At the same time, the realization of the appalling load of suffering of this world-in-crisis brings back into the centre of the Christian community and of its missionary witness the scandal of the Crucified. The rebuilding of the society cannot start but from its victims. The proclamation of God seems to make sense today only if it reaches out to the dehumanized human being, who thus becomes the privileged interlocutor of mission, and if it speaks again the Pauline language of God’s kenosis: the event of God who in Jesus-the victim shares the passion of the world and suffers his own passion of love for the little ones and the last, in order to claim them for himself as his own beloved children, to give a real chance of fulfilment to their dream and struggle of liberation and to care that they might have a fullness of life.
By proclaiming, in words and deeds, the event of God-Gift who makes of the other one as of myself an image of himself and unites us both as members of each other, Christian mission responds to the crisis of the liberal modernity according to which my fellowman like me is fundamentally a self-interested individual, and society just an agreement once again for one’s own interest. In the light of the Crucified, the missionary response to the present global systemic crisis and the consequent reconstruction of a horizon of meaning and of a moral framework take the shape of a liberating and ecumenical praxis that flows from the “greater charism” of love as a ‘capacity of becoming gift’. The circularity of gift becomes the missionary alternative to the logic of profit.
It is at this point that, by letting this reality of today’s world and of the new missionary map, with its renewed intelligence of the mystery and messianic ministry of Christ, challenge the Comboni’s heritage and the history of the Comboni Institute, we can ask what it means to be Comboni missionaries today.
1) First of all, could we not say that, beyond the cultural, religious and theological schemes of his time, the charism that through Daniel Comboni has passed to his followers is the capacity of sharing the active and messianic passion of Jesus for the liberation and fullness of life of those who are the last and marginalised? In the new historical situation, when not only the borders between ‘believers’ and ‘non-believers’ run a bit everywhere within the globalized world, but much more when God’s eclipse and religious fundamentalisms compete for the same space, could not the missionary proclamation of God as constitutive of Comboni charism take the shape of the gift of being able to witness the crucified God, who lives at the centre of the passion of the world and reveals himself “sub forma contraria”, as a self-expropriating gratuity, in the otherness of those who suffer? Could not this reinterpretation of Comboni charism re-qualify the spirituality itself of the “Heart of the Good Shepherd” in a messianic sense so that the ‘gift of oneself’ from being a personal spiritual dimension becomes a paradigm of a liberating missionary praxis and a prophecy of a world made new?
2) Secondly, and regardless of the historical question of how Comboni imagined the future of his institute, it is however clear that he was interested first of all that the Church of his time be blown by a missionary wind of commitment to the “the poorest and most abandoned”. In the light of a hermeneutics of charism according to which the event challenges the text of tradition, could not this primigenial intentionality of the Founder find today its expression in the fact that the Comboni Institute from being a group of people entrusted with mission turns more and more into a ‘movement’ that rouses the local Churches, each one in its own place and all together in their mutuality and missionary openness, to live the com-passion of God for the last and his dream of the world as a feast of fraternity? In this perspective, would not the various missionary Institutes, which already in their foundation have a lot in common, be required by the new context of a global world and global mission to form a missionary “network” , as expression and mediation of a Church-in-mission?
3) Thirdly, Comboni identified in the Africans of his own time the “last and the excluded”, whom God was empowering as protagonists of their own regeneration and subjects of their own history to take their place as “nigra margarita” in the Church of God and thus in that new world of which the Church is the pledge. Today, the last and excluded fill the roads of the world so much so that we speak of a ‘globalization of poverty’, while, on the other hand, the African world by large continue to be in a sub-human condition. In such situation, would not the option for Africa still represent an indicative of Comboni charism, not as an exclusive choice, but as a performative sign of mission in its dimension of journey with the last and excluded in view of liberation from the demons that harass today’s society? At the same time, in the present circumstances of the new African diaspora and of the world interdependence, would not an ‘African’ mission require to be done contemporaneously also in the post-Christian North, where actually many of the evils that plague the South have their roots?
Such an option for Africa
Such an option for Africa as the performative sign of a journey of communion and liberation with the last ones would then represent a criterion both for where and how to be Comboni missionaries in Africa and for identifying other spaces, besides Africa, to do mission.
4) Finally, in a world that becomes more and more plural and yet continues to grow more than ever “without the other”, when not “against the other”, should not the traditional “crossing the borders” as mark of the missionary charism be reinterpreted and relocated? Not only does it seem necessary to move from a discourse of geographical borders to that of anthropological borders, in the sense of an exodus from oneself – towards others, who thus in their differences, with their personal story, their culture and their religious experience become the subjects themselves of mission and the interlocutors in the discourse of evangelization. But furthermore, when those anthropological borders cross today every place and appear as structures of exclusion, is not perhaps the imperative itself of our charism to be there at those borders and to live them, through an insertion in their own reality with a will of encounter and daily communication, in order to transform them from barriers of seclusion and separation into spaces of a new imagination of the world and in laboratories of a new multifaceted humanity, and thus renew the praxis of Jesus who used to sit at table and eat with all, by privileging however those with whom nobody wanted to eat? Wouldn’t it, then, become a missionary priority to have communities there where the borders are suffered most, in which the choice of the impoverished and marginalized people is concretized in a daily life together with them and in a shared journey of liberation and transformation of reality (the so called communities of [physical] insertion)?

